JPMorgan upgrades Freshpet to “Overweight,” sees competitive threats as overblown

Tweet Share E-mail

0 shares

Freshpet shares fell 9% following its first-quarter earnings report despite a sales beat and higher guidance, a decline JPMorgan described as an overreaction tied largely to concerns over new entrants in refrigerated pet food.

The report highlighted growing competition from brands such as Kirkland, The Farmer’s Dog, and General Mills’ Love Made Fresh. However, JPMorgan said market data shows these challengers have gained limited traction so far, with Freshpet still controlling the overwhelming majority of refrigerated dog food sales.

Analysts argued that Freshpet’s vertically integrated manufacturing system and more than 39,000 company-owned refrigerators installed at retailers create barriers that rivals will struggle to replicate. Unlike many consumer packaged goods brands, competitors cannot simply occupy Freshpet’s shelf space without retailers installing additional refrigeration units.

JPMorgan also pointed to improving profitability driven by new manufacturing technology. The bank believes Freshpet could soon raise its long-term gross margin target above the current “greater than 48%” goal, potentially reaching 49% as upgraded production lines improve efficiency for bagged products.

The analysts forecast revenue to rise from $1.1 billion in 2025 to $1.32 billion by 2027, while EBITDA is expected to increase from $196 million to $260 million over the same period.