Tesla (TSLA) Model S Fire Changes Everything and Nothing at All
Tweet
Share
E-mail
Get Alerts TSLA Hot Sheet
Price: $406.43 +1.82%
Rating Summary:
29 Buy, 26 Hold, 16 Sell
Rating Trend: = Flat
Today's Overall Ratings:
Up: 5 | Down: 11 | New: 27
Rating Summary:
29 Buy, 26 Hold, 16 Sell
Rating Trend: = Flat
Today's Overall Ratings:
Up: 5 | Down: 11 | New: 27
Join SI Premium – FREE
Despite some vigorous analyst defense this morning, shares of Wall Street darling Tesla (NASDAQ: TSLA) remain under pressure as details of the recent Model S fire come to light. After dropping 6.2% on Wednesday, shares are down another 3.2% in pre-open trade Thursday.
Tesla confirmed the fire Wednesday near Seattle, saying it was contained to the front of vehicle and never entered the interior cabin. It was caused by a "direct impact of a large metallic object to one of the 16 modules within the Model S battery pack," a Tesla spokeswomen said. "Because each module within the battery pack is, by design, isolated by fire barriers to limit any potential damage, the fire in the battery pack was contained to a small section in the front of the vehicle," the spokeswoman added.
A New York Times article on the Model S fire, quoting fireman at the scene, noted that they thought they initially had the fire extinguished shortly after arriving only to have it reignite under the vehicle. Capt. Kyle Ohashi said the battery pack proved difficult to extinguish.
Shares have reacted negatively to the news as it threatens to impact demand given the company's sterling safety record is now at risk.
However, some analysts believe the company can withstand the event with little impact on demand. Deutsche Bank analyst Dan Galves sees several issues that may mitigate the negative impact on safety perception: 1) After 83mn miles of Model S driving, 12 significant accidents, and extreme crash-testing by U.S. Safety regulators, this is the first fire in a Tesla vehicle (on avg, 1 vehicle fire occurs on US roads every 20MM miles). 2) The fire resulted from a collision. If this had been a spontaneous incident with no catalyst (e.g. in a garage), the impact would be significantly worse. 3) This was not an explosion. The fire started gradually and the vehicle performed as designed in terms of warning the driver and venting the fire outside of the driver compartment. 4) Tesla's ability to monitor the vehicle systems remotely will enable a detailed report on the root cause of the incident.
Galves said investors should view the fire as an isolated incident and should continue to buy the stock.
Tesla confirmed the fire Wednesday near Seattle, saying it was contained to the front of vehicle and never entered the interior cabin. It was caused by a "direct impact of a large metallic object to one of the 16 modules within the Model S battery pack," a Tesla spokeswomen said. "Because each module within the battery pack is, by design, isolated by fire barriers to limit any potential damage, the fire in the battery pack was contained to a small section in the front of the vehicle," the spokeswoman added.
A New York Times article on the Model S fire, quoting fireman at the scene, noted that they thought they initially had the fire extinguished shortly after arriving only to have it reignite under the vehicle. Capt. Kyle Ohashi said the battery pack proved difficult to extinguish.
Shares have reacted negatively to the news as it threatens to impact demand given the company's sterling safety record is now at risk.
However, some analysts believe the company can withstand the event with little impact on demand. Deutsche Bank analyst Dan Galves sees several issues that may mitigate the negative impact on safety perception: 1) After 83mn miles of Model S driving, 12 significant accidents, and extreme crash-testing by U.S. Safety regulators, this is the first fire in a Tesla vehicle (on avg, 1 vehicle fire occurs on US roads every 20MM miles). 2) The fire resulted from a collision. If this had been a spontaneous incident with no catalyst (e.g. in a garage), the impact would be significantly worse. 3) This was not an explosion. The fire started gradually and the vehicle performed as designed in terms of warning the driver and venting the fire outside of the driver compartment. 4) Tesla's ability to monitor the vehicle systems remotely will enable a detailed report on the root cause of the incident.
Galves said investors should view the fire as an isolated incident and should continue to buy the stock.
Serious News for Serious Traders! Try StreetInsider.com Premium Free!
You May Also Be Interested In
- GLJ Research on Tesla (TSLA): 'We’re Still Short'
- SpaceX: New Street Research sees 22% upside from proposed IPO price
- Jefferies says Europe battery electric vehicle sales jump in May
Create E-mail Alert Related Categories
Analyst Comments, Corporate News, Insiders' BlogRelated Entities
Deutsche Bank, TeslaSign up for StreetInsider Free!
Receive full access to all new and archived articles, unlimited portfolio tracking, e-mail alerts, custom newswires and RSS feeds - and more!
