McDonald's Coffee Poses Material Threat to Starbucks -Deutsche Bank (MCD, SBUX)

May 20, 2008 9:26 AM EDT
Get Alerts MCD Hot Sheet
Price: $285.53 -0.44%

Rating Summary:
    31 Buy, 14 Hold, 1 Sell

Rating Trend: Up Up

Today's Overall Ratings:
    Up: 16 | Down: 24 | New: 55
Join SI Premium – FREE
Deutsche Bank issued a research report this morning highlighting several reasons why McDonald's (NYSE: MCD) specialty coffee roll-out poses a "material competitive threat to Starbuck's (Nasdaq: SBUX) core business - premium coffee beverages." The firm maintains a Hold rating on shares of Starbucks.

The firm calls McDonald's coffee roll-out a "3-pronged attack of lower price points, massive distribution and speed/convenience..." which could create a $0.05 incremental EPS risk for Starbucks over the next year. Specifically, Deutsche calculates, based on test markets, that McDonald's could sell 30-40 units/day (which is only 30% of the company's long-term target range), implying $35,000 per store or $490 million on a system-wide basis. According to Deutsche, this amount of revenue comes without advertising or word-of-mouth growth, but still represents 6-6.5% of Starbuck's coffee sales. Eventually, Deutsche believes McDonald's coffee sales could reach $1.4 billion in 2009, which would be close to 25% of Starbuck's estimated U.S. coffee sales.

Deutsche believes shares of Starbucks will remain range bound for some time as "soft 2008 performance continues, no sign of a turnaround has emerged, and current share prices already discount significant improvement in 2009."

Starbucks Corporation engages in the purchase, roasting, and sale of whole bean coffees worldwide.

You May Also Be Interested In

Related Categories

Analyst Comments, Insiders' Blog

Related Entities

Deutsche Bank